When the Deal Closes, the Valuation Work Isn’t Over: Purchase Accounting Considerations Across the Oil and Gas Value Chain

By Kyle Turner, Whitley Penn Valuation Services Partner; Robert Allen, Whitley Penn Valuation Services Partner, and Robert Brand, Whitley Penn Valuation Services Associate Director

Key Takeaways

  • Purchase accounting under ASC 805 determines what a buyer actually acquired. In an energy business combination, the purchase price is allocated to acquired assets and assumed liabilities based on acquisition-date fair value.
  • Fair value may differ significantly from historical book value. Oil and gas assets such as reserves, pipelines, processing facilities, equipment, contracts, and customer relationships may require separate valuation in a purchase price allocation.
  • A purchase price allocation can affect earnings for years after an acquisition. Fair values, useful lives, intangible assets, earnouts, and goodwill can influence future depreciation, amortization, and financial reporting.

An upstream producer acquires a portfolio of oil and gas properties. A midstream company purchases a gathering and processing system. A downstream operator acquires a terminal business. An oilfield services company buys a competitor and its equipment fleet.

The businesses and assets may look very different, but each transaction raises a similar question after closing: What did the buyer actually buy, and how should it be reflected in the financial statements?

For transactions accounted for as business combinations, answering that question generally involves applying the acquisition method under ASC 805, including measuring acquired assets and assumed liabilities at acquisition-date fair value and recognizing goodwill when appropriate.

In the energy industry, however, the assets being valued and the issues involved can look dramatically different from one transaction to another.

The purchase price must go somewhere.

A buyer may think about an acquisition relatively simple: “We paid $50 million for this business.” Purchase accounting asks a different question: “What did the $50 million actually buy?” The answer depends heavily on where the acquired business sits in the energy value chain.

Assets Commonly Recognized or Remeasured

Industry segment Examples of assets commonly recognized or remeasured
Upstream
  • Oil and gas properties and reserve interests
  • Leasehold and mineral interests
  • Wells and production equipment
  • Gathering infrastructure
Midstream
  • Pipelines and gathering systems
  • Processing plants, compression equipment and storage facilities
  • Customer relationships
  • Gathering, processing and transportation agreements
Downstream
  • Refineries, terminals, storage and distribution assets
  • Customer relationships
  • Trade names
  • Supply, throughput and offtake arrangements
Oilfield services
  • Machinery and equipment; vehicle and rental fleets
  • Facilities
  • Customer relationships and trade names
  • Technology and other identifiable intangible assets
Industry segment Examples of assets commonly recognized or remeasured
Upstream •  Oil and gas properties and reserve interests

•  Leasehold and mineral interests

•  Wells and production equipment

•  Gathering infrastructure

Midstream •  Pipelines and gathering systems

•  Processing plants, compression equipment and storage facilities

•  Customer relationships

•  Gathering, processing and transportation agreements

Downstream •  Refineries, terminals, storage and distribution assets

•  Customer relationships

•  Trade names

•  Supply, throughput and offtake arrangements

Oilfield services •  Machinery and equipment; vehicle and rental fleets

•  Facilities

•  Customer relationships and trade names

•  Technology and other identifiable intangible assets

Not every transaction will include all of these assets, and the accounting ultimately depends on the particular facts and circumstances.

There is also an important threshold question in some energy transactions: whether what was acquired meets the accounting definition of a business or instead represents an asset acquisition. That distinction can be particularly relevant in acquisitions of upstream properties and infrastructure assets, and the accounting models differ.

Not every transaction will include all of these assets, and the accounting ultimately depends on the particular facts and circumstances.

There is also an important threshold question in some energy transactions: whether what was acquired meets the accounting definition of a business or instead represents an asset acquisition. That distinction can be particularly relevant in acquisitions of upstream properties and infrastructure assets, and the accounting models differ.

Oil pipeline in the sunset

Fair Value May Look Very Different From Book Value

One of the first concepts management teams encounter in a purchase price allocation is that historical book values do not necessarily represent acquisition-date fair values.

Consider an oilfield services company with a large fleet of specialized equipment. Some of that equipment may have been purchased years ago and substantially depreciated. Its carrying value on the seller’s balance sheet may bear little resemblance to its current fair value.

The same issue arises elsewhere in the industry. A midstream system may contain pipelines and processing facilities constructed over decades. A downstream acquisition may include terminals or refinery infrastructure with historical costs that provide limited insight into current value.

Fair value under ASC 820 is based on a market-participant, exit-price framework. In practical terms, that means the valuation generally requires looking beyond the accounting records and understanding the assets themselves, including their age, condition, capacity, utilization and remaining economic life.

Oil pipeline in the sunset

Fair Value May Look Very Different From Book Value

One of the first concepts management teams encounter in a purchase price allocation is that historical book values do not necessarily represent acquisition-date fair values.

Consider an oilfield services company with a large fleet of specialized equipment. Some of that equipment may have been purchased years ago and substantially depreciated. Its carrying value on the seller’s balance sheet may bear little resemblance to its current fair value.

The same issue arises elsewhere in the industry. A midstream system may contain pipelines and processing facilities constructed over decades. A downstream acquisition may include terminals or refinery infrastructure with historical costs that provide limited insight into current value.

Fair value under ASC 820 is based on a market-participant, exit-price framework. In practical terms, that means the valuation generally requires looking beyond the accounting records and understanding the assets themselves, including their age, condition, capacity, utilization and remaining economic life.

Some Valuable Assets May Not Appear on the Balance Sheet

Physical assets tend to be relatively easy to identify. Other valuable assets can be less obvious.

A midstream company may have long-term gathering or processing arrangements supporting the economics of its system. An oilfield services company may have established relationships with major operators. A downstream business may have valuable customer relationships, trade names or contractual arrangements.

Because many of these assets were developed internally, they may never have appeared separately on the seller’s historical balance sheet. Following an acquisition, however, some may qualify for separate recognition.

That is one reason a PPA should not simply become an exercise in adjusting tangible assets to fair value and calling everything else goodwill.

Useful Lives Can Affect Earnings Long After Closing

Determining fair value establishes the opening balance sheet. Determining useful lives can influence earnings for years afterward.

Two acquired assets could each have a fair value of $10 million, but if one has a remaining useful life of five years and the other 20 years, the resulting depreciation or amortization expense will look very different.

This can be especially important in energy transactions, where pipelines, processing facilities, machinery, equipment and other long-lived assets may represent a substantial portion of the purchase price.

A purchase price allocation therefore does more than establish acquisition-date values. It can also establish years of future depreciation and amortization expense.

Earnouts Can Create Another Layer of Complexity

Acquisition agreements sometimes include earnouts or other contingent payments designed to bridge differences between buyer and seller expectations.

An oilfield services seller might receive additional consideration if the acquired business reaches certain EBITDA targets. Other arrangements could be tied to revenue, production, commodity prices or project milestones.

The maximum potential payment does not necessarily represent the fair value of that obligation at the acquisition date. Depending on the terms, the valuation may need to consider different potential outcomes, their likelihood, timing and risk. Certain contingent consideration arrangements can also require subsequent remeasurement after the acquisition.

So, even after the initial purchase price allocation is finished, some valuation work may continue.

Goodwill is the Residual, But It Should Still Make Sense

Once the identifiable acquired assets and assumed liabilities have been measured, the acquisition accounting may result in goodwill.

A significant amount of goodwill is not necessarily unusual or problematic. But the overall allocation should still make economic sense.

If management believed it was acquiring valuable infrastructure, contracted cash flows, customer relationships or other strategic assets, the resulting purchase accounting should be understandable in the context of that investment thesis.

That does not mean the PPA will mirror the buyer’s deal model. It does mean management should be able to understand and explain the result.

Get Ahead of the Process

The best time to begin thinking about purchase accounting is generally not several months after an acquisition closes.

Management can make the process considerably smoother by identifying potential valuation issues early and preserving the forecasts, asset information, contracts, reserve reports and other materials used to evaluate the transaction.

Goodwill is the Residual, But It Should Still Make Sense

Once the identifiable acquired assets and assumed liabilities have been measured, the acquisition accounting may result in goodwill.

A significant amount of goodwill is not necessarily unusual or problematic. But the overall allocation should still make economic sense.

If management believed it was acquiring valuable infrastructure, contracted cash flows, customer relationships or other strategic assets, the resulting purchase accounting should be understandable in the context of that investment thesis.

That does not mean the PPA will mirror the buyer’s deal model. It does mean management should be able to understand and explain the result.

Get Ahead of the Process

The best time to begin thinking about purchase accounting is generally not several months after an acquisition closes.

Management can make the process considerably smoother by identifying potential valuation issues early and preserving the forecasts, asset information, contracts, reserve reports and other materials used to evaluate the transaction.

That is particularly important in energy, where the underlying valuation questions can change considerably across upstream, midstream, downstream and oilfield services businesses.

The transaction may be complete when the money changes hands. But for CFOs, controllers, and financial reporting teams, one important question remains:

What did we actually pay for?

Answering that question is at the heart of translating the economics of the deal into the financial statements.

Get in Touch

Hover below to view contact information.
Headshot of Robert Brand

Robert Brand

Associate Director

Don't miss these other oil & gas insights & resources:

How Can We Help?

Take a moment to fill out the form and a member of our team will reach out to assist you. For more in-depth inquiries, click here.
Skip to content